On a quiet Tuesday morning in the sleepy village of Dundee, Michigan, a neighbor stepped into the familiar home of Cameron and Courtney Hulet. The front door was ajar — no surprise there. The couple was known for leaving it open.

But it was when the neighbor saw what was inside that everything took a chilling turn — marking the beginning of a mysterious story that baffled the police.

It was the kind of scene that might’ve seemed entirely ordinary in a quiet neighborhood — at least, on the surface.

It was a Tuesday morning in 2016, in the sleepy village of Dundee, Michigan, when one neighbor happened to glance into the home of Cameron and Courtney Hulet, a young couple who had recently moved to the area.

What she saw inside wasn’t alarming at first, but as she took in the strange stillness of the scene, something didn’t quite sit right.

The front door was wide open, just as it always seemed to be. In Dundee, a small town with a population barely pushing 5,000, everyone knew everyone, and nothing ever really seemed out of place.

But that would soon change.

What was once a quiet, close-knit community would become the center of a media frenzy.

When the neighbor stepped inside the Hulet home that morning, she was met with an unexpected and unsettling sight.

Read More Below